Discussion about this post

User's avatar
arthur brogard's avatar

Yes. Very true. And needs saying again and again so this welcome.

I would like to suggest we change the narrative, though, in regard to 'winning' and 'losing'.

Instead of 'Russia now effectively defeated Ukraine' I'd have 'Russia now effectively saved Ukraine'.

My point is that 'Ukraine' is the people.

We have a number of Orwellian mis-speaks and that's a major one: to always talk of a nation and kinda subconsciously or implicitly indicate we're talking of people when in fact we're merely talking of the govt or the manipulators behind that govt.

This is the most common. It is universal It is the norm. We speak of what 'America' has done, what 'Germany' is doing and so on, don't we? When the Americans and the Germans have actually done nothing at all: just their controllers, their out of control manipulative insane governments have done things.

It's common It is the norm. But it is not right.

A nation is its people. Simple as that.

One section of the ukrainian people have saved themselves, they declared independence and allied with Russia (after some eight years) and now they are going well.

The other section, some 30 million notionally at pre '14 figures, are in dire straights. Bankrupt, corrupted from within to horrific extent, probably as many as one million of them slaughtered on the battlefield, forbidden to leave the country, forbidden religions, forbidden languages, forbidden thoughts, attitudes, beliefs.... country being sold off and destroyed before their very eyes...

If Russia can take control of this then it has rescued them. It has saved them.

Not some fancy idle notion. Just look at the harsh realities. The truth. The facts. Are that 30 million in deep trouble or not? Who will/can help them?

Are they 'Ukraine' or is Ukraine a handful of plundering black marketeers, oligarchs, corrupt politicians, foreign schemers ?

To get a right view of things we need to drop this time honoured historians way of describing, viewing the world per 'nations' as though they exist independently of their people.

We need to turn to thinking of what matters, what it is really all about; people.

And if Russia can take control of kiev ukraine then it has, it will have, 'rescued', 'saved' 'ukraine (the people).

What the scheming corrupt amoral lunatic west wants to paint as a terrible possible outcome is actually the only hope that 30 million people have.

Expand full comment
mois78's avatar

Hi Eric happy Fourth. Thanks for your great work. Easy Ukraine will be part of Russia, and West Ukraine will be neutral…never part of NATO. As a matter of fact peace cannot take place unless NATO IS DISSOLVED.

Expand full comment
5 more comments...

No posts